FAQ's About Hiring an Editor

freedigitalphotos.net

I am often asked about editing, so clearly there is a need to talk about the issue. Here goes . . .

Is it necessary to hire an editor?
That's a loaded question. It depends. If you're planning to go the self-pubbing route, then yes. Absolutely. Get out there and find an editor already, sheesh. I don't care how stellar you think your skill with words is, you need an extra set of eyeballs to catch what you don't see, and I guarantee you, you will NOT see every glitch in your story.

If you're planning on subbing to a traditional publisher, then forking out the cash to hire an editor depends upon your writing ability. This is not the time for pride. Be honest. Get a second opinion other than your mother's.

How do I find an editor?
Word of mouth is the most reliable source. It weeds out the charlatans and junior high grammar failures. Ask around for references. Any editor worth hiring will have reviews from pleased clients, so yes, they should have experience. Here, I'll make it even easier and give you a referral. Elizabeth Ludwig combs through all my manuscripts before I send 'em out. You'll find her editing information HERE.

Networking is the best way to go about finding an editor, but if you're really stuck and can't find one or the one you want is too swamped at the moment, try the Editorial Freelancers Association (just make sure to check their references before you hire someone). And before you lay down cash for any editor, make sure their name doesn't show up on Preditors & Editors.

Aren't all editors the same?
Besides varying in hair color and propensity to eat asparagus (YUM!), editors generally specialize in a particular kind of editing. There's the macro editor who does a substantive edit, which looks for overall storyline ebb and flow and plot issues. Then there's a copy editor who will point out all your grammar, usage or style problems.

Is it really worth it?
You'll need to consider the return on your investment. If an agent or publisher is impressed with your clean and tight manuscript and you snag a contract, then yep. I'd say it's worth it. Of course, there are no guarantees. Sure there's a chance you cough up the bucks and you still don't attract any publishing attention. That's the writerly game, folks. On the flip side, though, if you put out writing that falls far short of perfection, you will get noticed and remembered in a very, VERY bad way.

Will you edit my story?
Nope. I am not a professional editor. I edit for a few, select writerly buddies because we swap our services with each other. Is that ingrown? Maybe. Is it fair? Not at all. Get over it.